Athletics Awards
Alumnae Cup
The Alumnae Cup is an award given to an Upper School student who demonstrates good sportsmanship throughout her time as a member of an athletic school team. She is a student who has strong leadership qualities and athletic ability. Recipients for this award will have played at least two sport seasons each school year.
Recent Recipients
Ava Baird
2024 | Recipient
This year's Alumnae Cup winner was just inducted into the 2024 4x3 class. She has made her mark as a leader and tremendous athlete on the Soccer, Basketball and Lacrosse teams.
This co - captain on the soccer team, played a pivotal role to our team’s success. As a center back she was vital to our defense and shut down tough opponents. A two time AAIS, starting player she played nearly every minute of every soccer game. Not only an incredible athlete, but she is also a dedicated teammate, coachable, and invested in the programs she participates in.
As captain of the Basketball team and AAIS ALL-Star, she played in every game this season and helped propel the team to the AAIS semifinals and a close NYSAIS first-round loss. On the basketball team, she brought a relentless intensity and grit, particularly shining on the defensive end, where her efforts were truly game-changing. Not only did she elevate her own performance, but she also had a remarkable ability to elevate the play of her teammates, making everyone around her better.
As the captain of the lacrosse team and a starter for every game, every year. The Alumnae Cup winner is a fierce competitor and always willing to challenge herself and her teammates, never afraid to hold herself accountable, she always found balance between leadership, accountability, commitment and self-improvement.
Eleanor Apps
2023 | 2023 Recipient | Class of 2023
Eleanor Apps is a tremendous two-sport athlete. She is a positive influence and leader on both teams she competes for, the type of leader who always returns to help put equipment away after every practice and game. She leads with kindness and compassion.
As the starting goalkeeper on the Varsity Soccer team, Eleanor was an absolutely pivotal player. In 2021, she earned Defensive Player of the Year for her vital role in the team, conceding only 10 goals in 14 games. In 2022, she received the same award, but the team (mostly due to her) only conceded three goals in 15 games. She is a dynamic presence on the field, explosive and impactful in the goal.
As a softball player, Eleanor carried the bulk of the offense at the plate with more extra-base hits than anyone on the team, including four home runs, one out of the park, and a grand slam. She improved fielding and anchored first base.
Eleanor Apps demonstrates sportsmanship and is a superior role model for all to see.
Natalie Weiner
2022 | 2022 Recipient
Natalie has played three sports each school year and her excitement and enthusiasm for running is demonstrated in and out of practice each day. She gets other students excited, shares resources and shows up each day ready to work her hardest.
One example of her fire can be seen in her races. She continues to push the whole way through and brings her teammates along with her. She is not one to let the fatigue at the end of a race get in the way of fighting for every spot, inch and second she can get. After each race, she thinks about what went well, what could be improved and how she wants to show up for the next race. In her role as a captain, she comes to the coaches with ideas for things that could be included in practices to build our program and develop even stronger runners.
- 1922
Winifred Dodd
- 1923
Gwendolyn Lewis
- 1924
Dorothy DuBois
- 1925
Dorothy DuBois
- 1926
Marianne Stevenson
- 1927
Martha Clark
- 1928
Martha Clark
- 1929
Frances Preston
- 1930
Margaret Preston
- 1931
Margaret Preston
- 1932
Sarah Key & Ruth Lambert
- 1933
Dorothy Moore
- 1934
Dorothy Moore
- 1935
Elizabeth Fay
- 1936
Janet Russell
- 1937
Barbara Brown
- 1938
Barbara Brown & Frances Kilpatrick
- 1939
Barbara Brown
- 1940
Anne Witherspoon
- 1941
Jane Thomson
- 1942
Judy Atterbury
- 1944
Monique James & Dorothy Schwarz
- 1945
Judy Baldwin
- 1946
Sharman Douglas
- 1947
Ursula Loengard & Miriam Bell
- 1948
Margaret Hanna
- 1949
Dexter Smith
- 1950
Ann Brunie
- 1951
Susan Scott
- 1952
Elinor Dean
- 1953
Barbara Hadley
- 1954
Sally Tilghman
- 1955
Betsy Loeb
- 1956
Susan Kirk & Cornelia Hanna
- 1957
Nancy Champe
- 1958
Barbara Ryan
- 1959
Barbara Ryan
- 1960
Dale Jones
- 1961
Josephine Bergen
- 1962
Gail Tenney
- 1963
Audrey Adams
- 1964
Mary Lynn Mahan
- 1965
Sara Baerwald
- 1966
Sarah Tenney
- 1967
Ingrid Nelson
- 1968
Townsend Given
- 1969
Betsy Steiner
- 1970
Juanita Dugdale
- 1971
Laura Klann & Arlene Smart
- 1972
Susan Conwell
- 1973
Sarah Stevens & Kady Gjessing
- 1974
Kandy Gjessing
- 1975
Hilary Henderson
- 1976
Elizabeth Reid
- 1977
Annik La Farge
- 1978
Joanne Low & Sarah Seggerman
- 1979
Paula Edelson & Leslie Gibson
- 1980
Paula Edelson & Leslie Gibson
- 1981
Susan McCray & Laura Wulf
- 1982
Lisa Bialkin
- 1983
Emily Gabler
- 1984
Perla Delson
- 1985
Julie Gerngross & Caryn Marooney
- 1986
Yvonne Karanas & Peyton West
- 1987
Gina Gardini & Katherine Gravy
- 1988
Jennifer Huggins & Jessica Burton
- 1989
Mary Margaret Gleason & Margot Wilkinson
- 1990
Victoria Schwartz & Tara Gleason
- 1991
Sarah MacArthur & Willa Ghitelman
- 1992
Natasha Foy
- 1993
Elizabeth Angell & Elisabeth Duffy
- 1994
Margaret Angell & Paula Campbell
- 1995
Amanda Eaken, Caroline Platt & Leigh Stearns
- 1996
Mary Louise Platt & Gabriella Pollack
- 1997
Kyle Ruth Labush
- 1998
Tenley Laserson
- 1999
Laura Bishop, Kate Hamill
- 2000
Rachel Cotton & Hilary Halstead
- 2001
Caroline Castillo
- 2002
Katie Blumenthal & Julia Raybould
- 2003
Margaret Gallin
- 2004
Jordan Hacker & Barbara Johnson
- 2005
Cathy Gallin & Nadine Lehner
- 2006
Emily Walker & Talia Chapman
- 2007
Corey Hacker & Kirsten Homma
- 2008
Lili Meyer
- 2009
Sofia McDonald
- 2010
Greta Anderson
- 2011
Jenna Santoro
- 2012
Madeline Abrams
- 2013
Kaitlin Hanss
- 2014
Martha Strautman
- 2015
Io Jones
- 2016
Sylvie Thode
- 2017
Ashley Prescod
- 2018
Grace Meade Sipp
- 2019
Alexandra Baird
- 2020
Olivia Frankel
- 2021
Courtney Burnett
- 2022
Natalie Weiner
- 2023
Eleanor Apps
- 2024
Ava Baird
Richard Stearns Award
With funds raised by Upper School students in 1993 in memory of Richard B. Stearns Jr., father of Hope ’91 and Leigh ’95, this award is given to an Upper School student whose perseverance, sense of teamwork and love of sport have been sources of inspiration to others. While not precluding athletic ability, the focus of the award is not on talent, but spirit. These qualities and a genuine joy for the game were all exemplified by Rick Stearns. Recipients of this award will have played at least two sports seasons each year
Recent Recipients
Eleanor Nangle
2024 Recipient
This year's Stearns Cup winner was just inducted into the 2024 4x3 class, for participating on the Soccer, Basketball, and Softball teams. As co-head of AA she has brought leadership, energy and enthusiasm to the role.
After recovering from a serious knee injury, this Soccer co-captain led by example with her hard work to heal and get back on the field. Always available to offer insightful feedback in team discussions and support her teammates. She also could be found being positive and cheering for her teammates when she was on the bench or on the field. She was able to be a friend to all and never stopped working to improve and have a positive impact on the team.
The resilience and determination this year's Stearns Cup winner showed during basketball season was exceptional. Still recovering from her injury, she displayed remarkable strength and skill on the court, shining brightly in crucial moments. Her defensive prowess was unparalleled, consistently making crucial stops and bolstering the team's strength from the bench.
Her coach describes her this way “Her leadership qualities were invaluable. As a senior leader, she exemplified what it means to be a great teammate, always willing to go the extra mile and eager to improve both individually and collectively. She is profoundly deserving of the Stearns Award, which honors outstanding athletes who exhibit not only exceptional skill but also extraordinary character and leadership”
This Softball captain consistently works hard to improve herself while also dedicating time and energy to helping her teammates grow. Her coach says “Her encouragement and infectious positivity boost our team spirit, making every practice and game a joy. Her genuine love for the game and her determination to support and uplift her teammates make her a perfect embodiment of the Stearns Cup values”
She exemplified what it means to be a great teammate, always willing to go the extra mile and eager to improve both individually and collectively.
Alex Hayes
2023 | 2022 Recipient | Class of 2023
Alex Hayes is one of our 4x3 inductees and is the epitome of team spirit and school pride. She was the loudest and proudest at Homecoming, Mountain Day and Field Day. She is also a skilled, strong and determined athlete. She was an outstanding captain of the soccer team for two years, and when you watch her play, she always gives 100 percent effort. Not to mention—she knows how to score goals.
Alex also took on the role of elder statesman in both indoor and outdoor track this year. She was very good about herding the ninth graders on the indoor team to the check-in table on time, and could always be counted on to run up to the stands to grab a baton or check on a teammate. Even though she was injured for nearly all of the indoor season, she was a very positive influence and a fantastic role model for the younger members of the team. This trend continued during outdoor, and she was always an enthusiastic presence in the stands and on the sidelines when not competing.
Emily Wheeler
2022 | 2022 Recipient
This year's Stearns recipient is the definition of enthusiasm and excitement. She shows up to practice and her presence is felt in the most positive way. Her teammates enjoy being around her and coaches love working with her. She is a leader in everything she does (even if she doesn't always have the title).
Regardless of the sport, season or score, Emily's supportive voice could be heard on the bridle path in Central Park, on the basketball court at the Field House and on the track out at Ichan. She makes sure her teammates feel included and lifts their spirits with sugary snacks. When her track teammates were competing in indoor track (a team she is not even on), she made the trip to the Armory to scream, cheer and support.
As a thrower in track and field, Emily demonstrated similar adaptability and showed herself to be a resilient competitor. She always strives for greatness as an athlete, but more importantly as a person.
- 1994
Jessica Gilbert
- 1995
Alice Liddell
- 1996
Susannah Hyland
- 1997
Jocelyn Simonson & Elizabeth Grubin
- 1998
Claire Newton
- 1999
Margo Johnston & Rebecca Kelly
- 2000
Caroline Nathan
- 2001
Marina Thompson & Elizabeth Tunick
- 2002
Maryangela Moutoussis
- 2003
Taline Pampanini
- 2004
Vasavi D. Reddy & Elizabeth David
- 2005
Audrey White
- 2006
Mia Hamamoto & Megan Shutzer
- 2007
Ella Massie Schuh
- 2008
Susanna Moller
- 2009
Elizabeth Moore
- 2010
Anna Santoleri
- 2011
Danielle Golub
- 2012
Sterling Sipp
- 2013
Ellie Sohm
- 2014
Victoria Kingham
- 2015
Rena Simkowtiz
- 2016
Charlotte Kim
- 2017
Kayla Gillman
- 2018
Blake Faucher
- 2019
Isabel Stern
- 2020
Leyla Theunissen
- 2021
Alex Gottlieb
- 2022
Emily Wheeler
- 2023
Alex Hayes
- 2024
Eleanor Nangle
Higginson Cup/Edna H. Carling Cup
The Edna H. Carling Cup, formerly known as the Higginson Cup, is given to a student in the Middle School who displays excellent athletic ability, fine sportsmanship and strong leadership skills in both PE and as a member of her school teams. Recipients for this award will have played at least two sports during both 7th and 8th grade years.
The change in name occurred sometime between 1974 and 1976.
Recent Recipients
Alex D.
Recipient
This year's Carling Cup winner is a team player who has given her all for three seasons since 5th grade playing on the Volleyball, Basketball, and Softball teams. This athlete is hard-working, and dedicated, she also demonstrates a love of sports each time she sets foot on the court or field. Always working to be the best competitor, she truly excels as a team leader. Often voted to be a Red/White captain, this thoughtful, kind, inclusive, and funny student is an amazing teammate and role model for her peers. She leads with unwavering spirit and dedication in everything she does.
Eleni L.
2023 | 2023 Recipient
Eleni Lejas is a three-sport athlete who played on the Varsity Soccer team, the AAIS regular season champion. Eleni always demonstrates a positive attitude and a strong desire to improve. Whether in the game or on the sidelines, she supported and encouraged her teammates. A talented player, she is poised to be a future leader within Brearley Athletics.
On the Middle School basketball team, Eleni displayed leadership qualities by motivating and electrifying her teammates. She was always willing to play any position and continually embraced challenge.
As the first baseman of the Middle School Softball team, Eleni also encouraged her teammates and served as an excellent communicator on the field. She comfortably shared ideas with the coaches and was always there to lend a helping hand.
Eleni Lejas is a wonderful role model with a warm smile and excellent work ethic.
Suhani P
2022 | 2022 Recipient
Suhani Pandya exemplifies all of the qualities of this award! As a middle school basketball team member and leader, she was dedicated, driven and a reliable competitor. Curious and up for any challenge, she always looked to improve her game and responded beautifully to feedback. All her P.E. instructors and coaches loved working with her this school year. She is also a standout P.E. student who has high-level skills and is consistent, kind and inclusive.
- 1922
Phyllis Baker
- 1923
Eileen Creevey
- 1924
Ruth Besson
- 1926
Frances Brewster
- 1927
Virginia Douglas
- 1928
Sarah Key
- 1929
Mary Jopling
- 1930
Elsie Lawson
- 1931
Elsie Lawson
- 1932
Mary Virginia Ball
- 1933
Margaret Titus
- 1934
Mary Halsey
- 1935
Barbara Brown
- 1936
Patricia Ryan
- 1937
Adrienne Moore
- 1938
Audrey Talmage
- 1939
Charlotte Hubbard
- 1940
MayField Manny
- 1941
Anne Macdonald
- 1942
Jaqueline Talmage
- 1944
Miriam Bell
- 1945
Linda Barrett
- 1946
Mabel Chrystie
- 1947
Bickley Flower
- 1948
Phyllis Nauts
- 1949
Kate Barrett
- 1950
Sally Tilghman
- 1951
Elizabeth Loeb
- 1952
Elizabeth Crocker & Susan Kirk
- 1953
Nancy Champe
- 1954
Ann Carlton
- 1955
Barbara Ryan & Julienne Michel
- 1956
Dale Jones
- 1957
Josephine Bergen
- 1958
Gail Tenney
- 1959
Audrey Adams
- 1960
Susan Davenport & Fifi Delacorte
- 1961
Nancy Ganz
- 1962
Laura Nields
- 1963
Catherine Bancroft
- 1964
Townsend Given
- 1965
Diane Straus
- 1966
Liza Little
- 1967
Ann McDonald
- 1968
Ann McDonald
- 1969
Sheila Richardson
- 1970
Kandy Gjessing
- 1971
Elizabeth Hauge
- 1972
Lisa Reid
- 1973
Susan Jameson
- 1974
Ali Bartle
- 1976
Leslie Gibson & Amy Jedlicka
- 1977
Julia Erhart & Susan McCray
- 1978
Lisa Bialkin & Rebecca Foster
- 1979
Emily Gabler & Victoria Labalme
- 1980
Rachel Bacon & Perla Delson
- 1981
Rebecca Leonard & Faith Sedlin
- 1982
Jennifer Wadsworth
- 1983
Samantha Fingleton, Rachel Hall & Margaretta Olton
- 1984
Christine Giusio & Leyla Morrissey
- 1985
Ilumai Kurik & Georgia Levenson
- 1986
Sidaya Moore
- 1987
Cynthia Peters
- 1988
Alexa Zesiger
- 1989
Lisa Lefkowitz & Margaret Smith
- 1990
Jessica Gilbert & Paula Campbell
- 1991
Alice Liddell & Lili Stearns
- 1992
Emily Israel & Lexer Quamie
- 1993
Sharese Bullock, Elizabeth Grubin & Amanda Leader
- 1994
Katherine Brodsky, Catherine Gowl and Kathryn Tokieda
- 1995
Nathania Nisonson & Laura Bishop
- 1996
Rachel Cotton, Emily Colgan Matson & Caroline Nathan
- 1997
Elizabeth Perkowski & Elizabeth Tunick
- 1998
Katharine Blumenthal & Maryangela Moutoussis
- 1999
Hannah Baker, Frances Frances Cashin & Anina Nolan
- 2000
Maren Jinnett, Barbara Johnson & Fiona McFarland
- 2001
Rebecca Chapman, Elisabeth McMorris & Sarah Sherman
- 2002
Talia Chapman & Susan DeWolf
- 2003
Haley Cohen, Lee Evangelakos & Catherine Miller
- 2004
Lili Meyer & Susanna Moller
- 2005
Charlotte Kaye & Anjali Itzkowitz
- 2006
Katherine Walker & Anna Santoleri
- 2007
Bess Lovern & Jenna Santoro
- 2008
Madeline Abrams
- 2009
Kaitlin Hanss
- 2011
Rachel McMahon
- 2012
Sylvie Thode
- 2013
Ashley Prescod
- 2014
Caitlin Shoemaker
- 2015
Alexandra Baird
- 2016
Leyla Theunissen
- 2017
Charlotte Andreano
- 2018
Emily Wheeler
- 2019
Caroline Lee
- 2020
Madeleine Hutchinson
- 2021
Katya G.
- 2022
Suhani P.
- 2023
Eleni L.
- 2024
Alex D.
Snyder Coaching Achievement Award
This award, named for longtime coach and teacher, Lorre Snyder, honors exemplary achievement by a head coach, assistant coach, or coaching staff.
Recent Recipients
Lorre Snyder
Recipient
The International Coaching community defines a coach as someone who:
-helps a person change in the way they wish and helps them go in the direction they want to go.
-supports a person at every level in becoming who they want to be.
-builds awareness, empowers choice and leads to change.
Tonight we are going to start off our evening honoring a special Coach and Teacher who exemplifies this definition.
You have been a committed coach and teacher at Brearley since 1991. You have coached and taught countless sports and physical education classes. You have been the leader of MSAA and a passionate advocate for the growth and development of our middle school sports program. You have certified hundreds of students in CPR and You are someone who always volunteers to help. You can also be depended on for a funny story or two.
Coach Snyder it is my pleasure to have the opportunity to honor you with the 2024 Coach’s Achievement award. This award is given every year to a head coach, assistant coach or entire coaching staff that has demonstrated outstanding achievement.
Today we are honoring your 33 years of coaching and teaching by renaming our Coaches award after you. Moving forward “The Synder Coaching Achievement Award” will be given to coaches who reflect your passion and commitment to Brearley sports. Please accept this year's Coach Achievement award for your years of extraordinary dedication to Brearley sports.
This special blanket was created for you with years of Brearley homecoming, field day, and other event shirts. We hope that through looking at this blanket you will be reminded how much the Brearley Community appreciates your selfless work.
Thank you, Lorre and we all are wishing you a healthy and productive retirement.
Cait Bradley
2023 | 2023 Recipient
When we think about a coach being the “face of a program,” we typically think about coaches who have been with their teams for decades and decades. We think of Bill Belichick and the Pats, John Wooden at UCLA, Pat Summit at the University of Tennessee, and so on. This coach, despite having been at Brearley for less than a decade, has established herself as virtually synonymous with cross country. Indeed, Brearley cross country and Cait Bradley are just like PB and J—it is nearly impossible to think of one without immediately thinking of the other.
For the past eight years, the cross country team has flourished with Coach Bradley at the helm. The team has grown to the size of a small army—or a thundering herd of bulls! Cross country has finished in the top five at NYSAIS Championships twice and won AAIS Championships in 2021. However, building a strong cross-country program is not merely about results on Milesplit; rather, it is about creating a positive and inclusive environment. Creating this type of environment comes very naturally to Coach Bradley and is her greatest strength as a coach.
Student-athletes often talk about the cross country team as a “friendly” team with “good vibes,” which is a direct result of Coach Bradley’s firm yet compassionate leadership. She takes the time to check in with every single athlete at the beginning of practice and is quick to modify workouts or lend a kind and sympathetic ear after a rough day. Most notably, she bravely risks car sickness after meets by checking in with every athlete on the bus while the bus lurches through traffic. Her athletes, students and colleagues know that she will always treat them with empathy and respect in every situation. When called upon to help with anything, she never fails to lend a hand.
Coach Bradley herself, however, is not without her own athletic accomplishments. After a solid track and cross country career at Fairfield High School, she ran at Dickinson College where she currently holds school records in three events: the 600 meters and mile for indoor track and the steeplechase for outdoor track. Other highlights of her collegiate career include second place at Divsion 3 cross country nationals in 2006 and third place in the steeplechase at D3 outdoor nationals in 2007. In 2008, she was the D3 national champion in the steeplechase. She has turned her focus to marathoning in recent years and has run two marathons under three hours.
To her embarrassment, I often use her as an example of how others could coach their teams in the organized, detailed, loving way she runs the cross country program. Brearley has been incredibly fortunate to count Coach Bradley among its faculty and coaches for the past eight years. We will all sorely miss her next year as she embarks upon a two-year journey to become a physician assistant.
Her genuine compassion for others combined with her stellar work ethic will certainly serve her well while working in healthcare. I think we would all be very relieved to see her if any of us ended up in the hospital for some reason. In recognition of her effective and empathetic leadership, the 2023 Coach of the Year Award goes to Coach Cait Bradley.
Whitney Jacobs
2022 | Recipient
Ms. Jacobs stepped into a role she doesn't ordinarily fill. Along with her co-directors and student choreographers, she created a dance performance that was intentional, beautiful, inclusive and meaningful. If you did not get a chance to see the work she did for winter 2022's “Evening of Dance”, I promise you missed something magical.
Coach Jacobs please come forward and accept this award in recognition of your outstanding achievement in leading the dance program this school year.
- 2022
Whitney Jacobs
- 2023
Cait Bradley
- 2024
Lorre Snyder
Championships
Varsity Badminton
- 2002-2003
- 2005-2006
- 2010-2011
Varsity Basketball
- 1980-1981
- 1993-1994
JV Basketball
- 1992-1993
- 1993-1994
- 1994-1995
- 1995-1996
- 1996-1997
- 1999-2000
- 1999-2000
- 2003-2004
Varsity Cross Country
- 1994-1995
- 1996-1997
- 1997-1998
- 2001-2002
- 2002-2003
- 2004-2005
- 2005-2006
- 2006-2007
- 2007-2008
- 2008-2009
- 2009-2010
- 2010-2011
- 2021-2022
Varsity Field Hockey
- 1994-1995
Varsity Lacrosse
- 1997-1998
- 1999-2000
- 2005-2006
- 2010-2011
Varsity Soccer
- 1989-1990
- 1993-1994
- 1994-1995
- 1995-1996
- 1996-1997
- 1997-1998
- 2010-2011
- 2011-2012
- 2018-2019
- 2022-2023
- 2023-2024
Varsity Softball
- 1991-1992
- 2007-2008
- 2008-2009
- 2010-2011
- 2015-2016
- 2017-2018
Varsity Swimming
- 1994-1995
- 2002-2003
- 2004-2005
Varsity Track & Field
- 1992-1993
- 1993-1994
- 1994-1995
- 1995-1996
- 1996-1997
- 1997-1998
- 1998-1999
- 2002-2003
- 2006-2007
- 2007-2008
- 2008-2009
- 2009-2010
- 2010-2011
- 2010-2011
Varsity Volleyball
- 1983-1984
- 1983-1984
- 1986-1987
- 1987-1988
- 1989-1990
- 1990-1991
- 1999-2000
- 2003-2004
- 2005-2006
- 2008-2009
- 2009-2010
- 2010-2011
- 2011-2012
- 2012-2013
JV Volleyball
- 1982-1983
- 1989-1990
- 1995-1996
- 1997-1998
- 1998-1999
- 2007-2008
- 2008-2009
- 2010-2011
- 2011-2012
- 2012-2013
- 2013-2014
- 2014-2015
- 2015-2016
Contact Brearley Athletics
Athletics Department
athletics@brearley.org